![]() |
| Image from ChatGPT |
A companion to the Social Security framework. Like that one, this is a proof of possibility, not finished statute. It shows that the arithmetic closes. The dials belong to experts, ideally in a room without lobbyists.
The premise
The United States spent $5.3 trillion on health care in 2024, about $15,500 per person, and left roughly 27 million people uninsured. About $4.2 trillion of that paid for the kind of care this plan covers. The rest is research, construction, public health, dental and vision, over-the-counter products, and private-pay custodial care.
The question this framework asks is narrow. Can that $4.2 trillion cover everyone, with almost nothing owed at the point of care, without spending more than the country spends now?
It can. The difficulty is not the amount. It is that the money arrives through a dozen channels, and about $940 billion of it comes directly out of household budgets as premiums, deductibles, and bills. Covering everyone means replacing those payments with a tax. The plan below does that and names the size of the tax.
The plan
Coverage. Everyone with a Social Security number or an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number is covered. There is no enrollment. Medicare needs enrollment today only because not everyone qualifies; when everyone qualifies, the first claim a provider submits is the enrollment. There are no premiums at any age. The existing 1.45 percent Medicare tax stays on the pay stub, and nothing new is withheld beside it. The VA health system folds in: its hospitals and clinics bill the plan like any other provider, and veterans can be seen anywhere.
At the point of care. Primary care, preventive care, mental health, chronic medication, emergency care, maternity, and pediatrics cost nothing. Discretionary use carries a modest flat copay: a specialist without a referral, a brand drug when a generic exists, the emergency room for a non-emergency, elective imaging. Copays are capped at $500 a year. They do not vary with income, because the administrative layer that would require costs more than it saves.
Money that stays where it is. Federal health spending continues. The Medicare payroll tax continues. States continue paying their share of Medicaid, just to the new plan - which replaces Medicaid. None of this is new money.
Employers. Each employer pays a legacy assessment equal to 90 percent of what it spent on health coverage per full-time employee before the law, multiplied by its current headcount. A shrinking firm pays less and a growing firm pays more. The assessment phases out over three to four years as a broad tax phases in. New firms pay a benchmark rate for their industry and size. Employers may drop their existing coverage whenever it suits them.
The reason for this design is that employer health costs vary enormously. Converting everyone to a uniform tax on day one would hand a windfall to firms with generous plans and could sink firms that offered little. Starting each employer at its own prior cost means nobody's bill changes abruptly.
The broad tax. This framework sizes the tax and leaves its design open. The size is in the arithmetic section below.
Integrity. The transition creates an obvious incentive to become a "new" company, and a less obvious one for promoters to sell that idea. The plan answers both.
- Successor liability and controlled-group rules, so a business cannot shed its history by reincorporating.
- A look-back that anchors each employer's baseline to the date the bill is introduced, so cutting benefits in anticipation gains nothing.
- Assessments computed by the government from payroll filings it already has. There are no retroactive refund claims to file, which removes the product that credit mills sold after the pandemic-era employee retention credit.
- A ban on contingency fees, with clawback that follows the preparer.
- A graduated limitations period: the normal period for ordinary errors, six years for substantial understatement, and no limit for fraud or sham re-formation.
- A voluntary safe harbor. An employer that files a short annual statement of headcount and cost, mostly pre-filled from existing returns, is presumed compliant. Declining to file carries no penalty beyond losing the presumption.
Protections. Plan revenue sits in a trust fund that cannot be diverted. Provider rates are set by formula, not by annual appropriation. Actuarial triggers adjust automatically when costs drift. Transition bonds cover the early years, when costs arrive faster than savings, and bondholders have standing to sue if Congress redirects the money.
Transition. Roughly $170 billion over five years supports workers displaced from insurance and billing jobs. Union-negotiated benefits are protected through a wage-recapture guarantee.
The arithmetic
All figures are annual, in billions, at 2024 levels. The payer totals come from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The scoping and savings estimates are this framework's own and should be read as accurate to within about $100 billion.
| Conservative | Optimistic | |
|---|---|---|
| Spending today on care the plan covers | 4,160 | 4,160 |
| Covering the uninsured and added use, net of copays | +340 | +260 |
| Savings | −430 | −925 |
| Plan spending | 4,070 | 3,495 |
| Federal money already committed, including Medicare payroll tax and VA | 1,875 | 1,875 |
| State Medicaid shares | 310 | 310 |
| Employer legacy assessment | 855 | 855 |
| Income and payroll tax on wages that used to be pre-tax premiums | 130 | 170 |
| Remaining to be raised | 900 | 285 |
The gap between the two columns is almost entirely a disagreement about savings. The conservative case assumes insurer overhead falls by $200 billion, provider billing costs by $100 billion, and drug spending by $100 billion. It assumes no savings from fraud reduction, since a single payer is also a single target. The optimistic case assumes more of each.
For comparison, a Yale preprint released in July 2026 estimated that a single-payer system would save $1.04 trillion a year. The conservative case here budgets for less than half of that.
The plan is sized to the conservative column. The broad tax is set to raise $900 billion during the transition. If savings come in above the conservative case, the excess is committed by formula: first to retiring the transition bonds, then to adding dental, vision, and hearing coverage, then to lowering the rate. A program that budgets for the pessimistic case and returns the difference is the only honest answer to the observation that government programs cost more than promised.
Who stops paying, and who starts
The $900 billion is not new spending. It replaces these payments:
- Workers with employer coverage: about $365 billion. The employee share of premiums averages roughly $1,400 a year for single coverage and more than $6,000 for a family. It disappears from the pay stub.
- Medicare beneficiaries: about $205 billion. Part B and Part D premiums and supplemental policies, roughly $3,000 per person.
- People who buy their own insurance: about $80 billion.
- People who get sick: about $290 billion. Deductibles and coinsurance, which fall on a small share of households in any given year.
Set against today, the private sector's total bill looks like this:
| Today | Conservative | Optimistic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Households: premiums and out-of-pocket | 937 | 0 | 0 |
| Employers: premiums, then assessment | 950 | 855 | 855 |
| New broad tax | 0 | 900 | 285 |
| Added tax on newly taxable wages | 0 | 130 | 170 |
| Total | 1,887 | 1,885 | 1,310 |
In the conservative case, households and employers together pay what they pay now. The difference is that everyone is covered, nobody faces a deductible, and losing a job no longer means losing coverage. In the optimistic case they pay about $575 billion less.
The costs, named
The tax grows as the assessment ends. The $900 billion figure holds only while employers are paying the legacy assessment. Once it phases out, the broad tax must also raise the $855 billion the assessment was carrying, for a steady-state total of $1.1 to $1.8 trillion. Employers today spend about 7.7 percent of wages on health coverage. If the entire steady-state amount were raised through an employer payroll tax, the rate would be 9 to 14 percent, of which 7.7 points replaces what they already pay.
"Employees pay nothing" is true on the pay stub. Economists generally expect an employer-side payroll tax to come out of future raises. Workers will fund part of this plan through slower wage growth. They fund the current system the same way, through premiums their employers pay in place of wages, so this is a continuation and not a new burden. It should still be said.
Most health-sector profit survives. Insurer profit disappears with the insurers. Drug-maker margins shrink under negotiation. Hospital, physician-group, and supplier margins are untouched, because the plan pays providers at roughly today's blended rates. That is a choice. Cutting provider rates would close most of the gap on paper and close hospitals in practice. The dial exists and is left for others to turn.
Retirees receive the largest transfer. Ending Medicare premiums relieves beneficiaries of about $205 billion that does not pass through payroll. Recovering any of it requires a tax that reaches retirement income. That belongs to the tax design, and to the eventual merger with the Social Security framework.
Some firms pay more. An employer that offered no coverage pays nothing under the legacy assessment and the full broad tax when it arrives. That is intended: those firms' workers are being covered.
What this plan does not solve
Custodial long-term care. Medically necessary care is covered from the first day. Extended custodial care is not, and no version of the arithmetic makes it self-funding. A realistic solution is means-tested, which would be the one exception to this plan's rule against income tests. It is unfinished business and is labeled as such.
Dental, vision, and hearing. These cost about $55 billion a year. They are deferred because the discipline of this framework was to fit inside existing money. They trigger automatically once the bonds are retired and the surplus covers them with a margin, and Congress can add them sooner whenever it chooses to pay for them.
Immigration. People with taxpayer identification numbers are covered because they pay in, about $6.5 billion a year in payroll taxes, and a system that collects from people and denies them care is not defensible. This is not immigration reform and does not substitute for it. Real reform is also the only durable fix for the aging of the population, which is the underlying pressure on both this plan and Social Security.
Things to consider
These are dials, not commitments.
- A statutory growth cap that triggers automatic review when spending rises faster than the economy.
- Provider rates. Left at current blended levels here. Any reduction is upside that this framework does not count.
- Healthy-behavior support. A single payer that covers a person for life has a financial reason to fund smoking cessation and early diagnostics that no insurer with annual turnover has. No penalties and no sin taxes.
- Artificial intelligence. Over two decades it may cut the cost curve, raise it, or extend lives by decades. The third outcome strains any health plan and is still the one to hope for. Funded retirement accounts under the Social Security framework are the hedge, and that case is made in the merged plan.
The point
The United States already pays for universal coverage. It does not receive it, because the money moves through premiums, payroll deductions, deductibles, and a dozen public programs, each with its own rules about who qualifies. This framework routes the same money through one payer, replaces household bills with a tax no larger than the bills, budgets for the pessimistic case, and returns the difference if the pessimists are wrong.
The arithmetic is the argument. Everything else is a dial.
Sources: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditure Accounts, 2024 (https://www.cms.gov/data-research/statistics-trends-and-reports/national-health-expenditure-data/nhe-fact-sheet). Savings, scope, and employer-cost figures are the author's estimates built on those accounts.
